Senate Democrats haven’t sworn in their new majority, and they’re already knifing each other.
Chuck Schumer swears he has the votes, and his rival is crying foul.
But the challenger just let slip his first move with the gavel, and it’s a naked power grab.
The Underdog Who Says He Has 15
US Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) wants Senator Chuck Schumer’s (D-NY) job, and he isn’t being shy about it.
The Maryland Democrat has started a public campaign to lead the new Democrat majority. It’s the first contested race for the post in three decades. He’s working the cable news circuit, he set up his own campaign website, and he tells anyone who will listen that voters rejected the “status quo.”
Schumer is keeping quieter. According to Fox News, 15 senators have publicly lined up behind him. He posted that “I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic leader.”
But Van Hollen’s public list is much shorter. Fox counts five backers who can actually vote: Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR), and two progressive senators-elect, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota. Retiring Senator Tina Smith (D-MN) backs him too, but she doesn’t get a vote.
Van Hollen still insists that as many as 15 senators are quietly with him. He also told Politico that Democrats were trying to move the secret-ballot vote earlier to hurt his chances.
“Let’s not rush into a coronation,” Van Hollen said.
That’s a funny complaint from a party that handed Kamala Harris the 2024 nomination before a single primary voter picked her.
And the website comes with a donate button. Van Hollen spent weeks hinting at a 2028 White House run. Then he told reporters at a Denver conference, “I’m no longer pursuing that.” One Democrat source told Fox News Digital, “At a minimum, it’s good for his base fundraising.”
What Van Hollen Wants to Do With 51 Votes
But the fundraising is a sideshow. The real news came out of that same Denver gathering, and most of the coverage skipped right past it.
Van Hollen told reporters he wants to scrap the filibuster, the Senate rule that makes most bills clear 60 votes.
“My personal view has been all along that the filibuster is an anti-democratic . . . provision. It’s not in our Constitution,” Van Hollen said, according to Fox News.
He kept going. “It was put in there by senators to enhance their power over the power of the people,” he said.
And he laid out the math for Just the News: “My personal opinion is that we need democracy in the United States Senate and that means allowing ultimately a majority of senators to answer the call of the American people, so that means 51 votes.”
Van Hollen has been after this for years. In 2021, he backed Joe Biden’s openness to reforming or eliminating the rule so Democrats could push through the Freedom to Vote Act, their federal takeover of state election law. In 2022, Democrats came up two votes short when then-Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema refused to go along.
He has even griped that the Senate itself is the problem. In remarks Grabien captured, Van Hollen said, “The Senate is already an anti-democratic institution, small ‘d’, right? I mean, two senators from Wyoming have the same number of votes as the two senators from California.”
The cattle ranchers outside Cheyenne might have something to say about that.
The Founders gave every state two senators on purpose, so the big states couldn’t flatten the small ones. Van Hollen treats that design like a bug.
Schumer Goes Quiet on the One Question That Matters
This is the part that should worry Republicans most. Schumer won’t say whether he’d keep the filibuster either.
Fox News reported that Schumer stayed silent when reporters asked whether he would back getting rid of the rule if Democrats win the White House in 2028. Senator Andy Kim (D-NJ) has warned colleagues that the move could cut both ways.
So one candidate wants the rule gone as soon as next year, and the other won’t rule it out. No one in the race is defending the 60-vote threshold. Whoever wins the secret ballot, the filibuster is in danger.
And the agenda behind that wall is no mystery. Democrats have spent years floating court packing, statehood for Washington, DC and Puerto Rico, amnesty for illegal aliens, sweeping gun restrictions, the PRO Act’s war on independent contractors, and an end run around the Electoral College. Every one of those schemes has hit the same 60-vote wall.
But President Trump still holds the veto pen through January 2029. Killing the filibuster now builds the machinery so it’s ready the moment a Democrat moves back into the White House.
Trump warned about exactly this when he pushed Senate Republicans to end the filibuster themselves. Senate Majority Leader John Thune refused. Republicans kept the rule in place as a courtesy to a party that is now openly planning to throw it out.
The Mandate Van Hollen Made Up
Van Hollen’s website says voters rejected the old way and that “to deliver, we need new leadership.”
But nobody went to the polls to gut the filibuster. In the NBC News exit poll, 63% of voters said the US made the wrong decision in taking military action against Iran, and 83% of those voters backed Democrats. Voters who called immigration enforcement crucial went Republican 58-40.
Those numbers show a backlash against the neocons who pushed Trump into the Iran war. They don’t show a country begging for a 51-vote Senate.
Schumer’s allies tell a different version of the story. Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee Chair Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) credits him with a 55-seat majority, which could reach 56 if Alaska flips. Senator Angus King (I-ME), who caucuses with Democrats, put it this way: “Why would you fire the manager when you just won the World Series?”
But the manager didn’t throw a single pitch. The hawks did that for him.
A Secret Ballot With No Receipts
Senate Democrats last fought over the top job in 1994, when Tom Daschle beat Chris Dodd 24-23 on a secret ballot. According to a Washington Examiner account, Daschle had campaigned for the post for eight months. Dodd ran for 23 days.
Van Hollen jumped in shortly after the midterms and has only a few weeks to close the gap. That may explain why he’s so worried about the calendar.
And Daschle went on to lead Senate Democrats for a decade, until South Dakota voters ousted him in 2004.
The vote comes in early December, behind closed doors, with no roll call for voters to check. Senators who campaigned against the old guard can vote however they like and never tell a soul.
So when those ballots get counted, will a single Democrat in the room be voting to save the filibuster?
Sources:
Fox News, “Schumer boasts early advantage in Senate power struggle as Dem rival warns against ‘coronation’”
Fox News, “Dem senators leave door open to nuking filibuster amid looming leadership shake-up”
Just the News, “Van Hollen believes Democrats should abolish Senate filibuster, rules out 2028 presidential bid”
Associated Press, “Van Hollen to challenge Schumer for Senate Democratic leader”
Grabien, “Sen. Van Hollen: It’s Time for the Filibuster to Go, the Senate Is Already ‘Antidemocratic’ Because Wyoming Has 2 Senators”
Maryland Reporter, “Van Hollen says he backs Biden’s openness to filibuster reform”
Anchorage Daily News, “A long-standing Senate tradition is being quietly undermined”
Washington Examiner, “Daschle Our Hopes” (1996)
South Dakota State University Archives, “Senator Tom Daschle at Work”
NBC News Exit Poll, 2026 midterms; 2026 midterm exit polling on immigration enforcement